Thank you to Wednesday Books for sharing a copy in exchange for my honest review.
When sixteen-year-old Georgia Avis discovers the dead body of thirteen-year-old Ashley James, she teams up with Ashley's older sister, Nora, to find and bring the killer to justice before he strikes again. But their investigation throws Georgia into a world of unimaginable privilege and wealth, without conscience or consequence, and as Ashley’s killer closes in, Georgia will discover when money, power and beauty rule, it might not be a matter of who is guilty—but who is guiltiest. A spiritual successor to the 2018 breakout hit, Sadie, I'm the Girl is a masterfully written, bold, and unflinching account of how one young woman feels in her body as she struggles to navigate a deadly and predatory power structure while asking readers one question: if this is the way the world is, do you accept it? A sapphic mystery/thriller from Courtney Summers about a small-town girl who is determined to make something of herself and also solve a murder along the way? Sign me up! A lengthy, ill-paced, abstract exploration of this girl’s pure vanity and ignorance? No thanks! After Sadie, I had much higher expectations for this book. Unfortunately, I was let down in a few ways. My issue is that much like the synopsis, the book fails to accurately describe what is happening to Georgia in a way that makes sense. It makes you feel like you should have understood what was happening from the get-go, which would be fine except for the fact that much of the novel hinges on that understanding of Georgia’s circumstances. She repeatedly gets involved in things that are much larger than her and makes them about her vanity and ego in ways that only a 16 year old girl could. For the titular character of a mystery novel, who is purportedly solving a murder, she’s more invested in her own sense of destiny and genuinely believes that her beauty will reap rewards against all advice from other characters. On one hand, I can admit that this is brilliant writing. Summers hooks readers into a full picture of Georgia’s manipulation by the powerful adults around her, including some truly brutal representations of sexual assault (CW for readers). Her prose is sharp and evocative, if a little vague. On the other hand, it was difficult to empathize with Georgia and stay invested in the story when she always seems so obsessed with herself. Her entire character comes across as ignorant of her situation, which is baffling since all the aspects are so obvious. The pacing is also off, especially in the last quarter of the book. Wrapping up the mystery in a winding and convoluted manner and having Georgia “realize” a number of things that readers could see right from the start in very little time doesn’t make for a smooth ride. I’m going to get into minor spoiler territory here to share some things that I just found truly bizarre:
Because of all this, I’m having a hard time truly recommending I’m the Girl to readers. I think if you’re going through Summers’ catalog, Sadie is more worth the hype. 3/5 stars.
0 Comments
Your comment will be posted after it is approved.
Leave a Reply. |
The BaronessHey, I'm Shreya! I love to read, write, travel, and drink tea. Disclosure: I am an affiliate of bookshop.org and I will earn a small commission if you click the above link and make a purchase.
Categories
All
Archives
June 2023
|